CRIME AND PUNISHMENT

Without getting into a polemic about who owns what and who was there first, the latest news flash out of Prime Minister Netanyahu’s office in Jerusalem that made it to the front page of the New York Times is simply shocking.

Netanyahu and his cabinet decided to withhold $100 million from the Palestinian Authority as a punishment for the Palestinians having gone before the United Nations in a quest for statehood. Further, the withholding of these funds which were taxes and custom payments due the Palestinians, was also a punishment because of secret meetings between the Palestinian Authority and the extremist group, Hamas. For weeks while the money was withheld, salaries of Palestinians throughout the West Bank and Gaza went unpaid. Children went hungry and men and women worked expecting to get paid and instead were told there was no money to pay them. How does that help to win hearts and minds?

This latest move by the Israeli government was shocking for several reasons. First of all, where is the understanding and sympathy for the Palestinians who did nothing different than the Israelis did decades ago when they went before the United Nations to claim a State for the Jewish people? And, where is the humanity within Israel, especially for a country and a people who understand suffering better than most, to create such hardship?

Israel claims it wants nothing more than peace and safety for their people. The Palestinians claim they want to live in peace on their own land. Both continue to use terror in all its forms to achieve their presumed goals. And, apparently when terror is not used and Palestinians take their cause to the United Nations, they are still punished with a more sophisticated form of violence.

For years, the reason that peace between Israel and the Palestinians has failed is complicated. Simply put, Israel refused to cede land and liberty because Palestinians were committing terrorist attacks and targeting Israeli civilians. When the attacks were aimed at Israeli settlements in what is considered occupied land, the result was mixed emotions—sympathy for the victims and sympathy for the attackers.

Some of us were outraged that Israel persisted in building settlements on disputed land when a moratorium on new Israeli outposts, villages or cities was an intricate part of any peace plan. When Palestinian attacks happened inside Israel—in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem or any other Jewish city, the hearts and minds of most people went with the innocent victims.

That is not to say that land is not the fundamental issue to any peace accord. It is and will continue to be until the Palestinians accept the existence of the State of Israel, which means at worst, that the Jewish State retreat to the 1967 borders. Unfortunately, there are zealots on both sides. There are the Israeli leaders who continue in arrogance to build settlements. And, while the Palestinian Authority has recognized Israel’s right to exist, their partners, Hamas and other extreme groups, have refused. For years the joke around Israel was that Palestinian extremists want peace alright, a piece of Tel Aviv, Haifa, Jerusalem and every other centimeter of Israeli land. Retreat to the 1967 borders in not an option for extremists on both sides.

Perhaps the time has come to redefine terror.

Terror is used to shock, intimidate, harm, and terrorize one’s enemy.

The most common form of terror is violence—as in suicide bombs, attacks on schools, murdering sleeping parents and children, targeted killings, Katushya rockets aimed across borders into Israeli cities, hijackings, to list a few.

If people wonder why terrorists attacked a pizzeria in Jerusalem, or Saudi terrorists crashed planes into the World Trade Center, the answer is always, “because they could.”  While terrorists do have a wish list of targets, it is mostly a matter of opportunity and more than often, the killers have to settle for second or third choices.

More subtle terror tactics are the weapons of the privileged. Financial terror, which the Israelis can and do use is because, once again, “they can.”

While it is true that Israelis do not strap on bombs and wander into a group of Palestinian civilians and detonate those bombs, it is also true that Palestinians use the only method of terrorism available to them. Strikes don’t mean anything. Refusing to work only means that there are hundreds of other Palestinians who are just waiting to take on any job available. There are no unions or organized labor forces. As for protests, they are a luxury in that part of the world and, as we have seen countless times, are met with bullets and tear gas.

To be perfectly clear, this is not an apology for blowing up innocent civilians. Rather, this is a warning that starving an entire population is as effective a terror tool as violence. Depriving people of food, shelter, medical care, and warmth is as violent a punishment as death—a slower and more angry death perhaps but still a death of hope, pride, and belief in the future.

What happened to a mutual understanding of wanting a homeland?

What happened to a mutual understanding of taking that quest to the United Nations?

What happened to memory?

More dangerous is what happens when both sides—Israeli and Palestinian—exert punishments that exceed the magnitude of the crime?

This entry was posted on Sunday, December 4th, 2011 at 4:13 pm and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

10 Responses to “CRIME AND PUNISHMENT”

  1. Tom Wallace Says:

    Barbara, A well reasoned and intelligent piece

  2. Williams Moving And Storage Boxes Says:

    Be sure to get more than one quote so you can take time
    to compare them and go through each one thoroughly. Buying your own home is one of the biggest investments and commitments that most people
    will experience in a lifetime. It is indeed a very
    expensive together with wearisome job to relocate
    your workplace collected from one of spot for a another.

    My web blog; Williams Moving And Storage Boxes

  3. Cheap Roger Vivier Shoes Says:

    MECCA» Blog Archive » CRIME AND PUNISHMENT
    Cheap Roger Vivier Shoes http://www.lepassagetoindia.com/rogervivier.asp

  4. cyber monday sales on north face jackets Says:

    coach patricias legacy bag michael kors totes to go fort worth north face arctic parka black friday In fact it is Parka Canada Goose lv billy white shoes johnson stats where is can i buy parkas in winnipeg christian louboutin mens sale shoes in the philipp lv billabong wallets quiksilver christian louboutin louis vuitton red bottom heels oakley golf specific sunglasses everton football jersey discount christian louboutin hola chica black on north face zephyr oakley sunglasses outlet 84 michael kors totes hello kitty rain boots for women 2013 cheap christian louboutin oakley sunglasses oo2043 north face jackets black friday deal ray ban original aviator when do north face jackets go on sale

  5. moving companies boca raton Says:

    On account of schedule development, your organization is likely to
    have the smallest achievable downtime which will benefit you essentially the most.
    If you are moving in New York City or are relocating to the
    big apple then you can get in touch with any of moving companies Nyc that can help you with it.
    Most of the Denver moving companies make use
    of quality packing boxes.

    Feel free to visit my web blog – moving companies boca raton

  6. Self tan Moisturiser Says:

    ) The skin dye type that is similar to Copper Tone tans.
    You can eliminate streaks by buying a high-quality spray
    tanning product like the solutions that Sun Labs provides.
    Women’s magazines featured women with glorious sun tans.

    Trying too many methods at once may make your
    skin look dried out, even crocodile-like. Once you have had a spray tan, wait for some time before you shower, and you can enjoy the effects of the
    perfect complexion for as long as seven days. However, there
    is no reason you can’t successfully apply a great looking self-tan at home.
    However, that does not mean that they are going without the
    authentic appearance of a tan that results from hours of
    sunbathing.   2) Extend your limbs completely while applying your sunless tanner
    spray and leave them that way until it dries. There are plenty of differing spray tan products available
    to buy, not all of which are up to standard.
    If you find a problem with a LV bag they will usually accept returns.

    My blog post – Self tan Moisturiser

  7. lolrptwitch.tumblr.com Says:

    As a jungle he is one of my favorite pick due to his bandage toss ability where you
    close the distance between you and enemy champions.

    Knowing when to move up and pressure and when to play
    defensive while free farming is the characteristic of not only a great ADC but of any good laner in League of Legends.
    The list of jersey types are rather extensive with there being authentic NFL
    jerseys that are made for all ages and both genders, such as youth jerseys,
    personalized, throwback, and much more.

    my blog: rp codes generator [lolrptwitch.tumblr.com]

  8. Speedy Louis Vuitton Noe Bag Says:

    any and all lesser and you approach ordering old.
    Speedy Louis Vuitton Noe Bag http://aliabrahimi.com/IGK/Speedy-Louis-Vuitton-Noe-Bag-031385.hhtml

  9. sun gym victorian clothing for sale Says:

    It is very important to find chic ball gown wedding dresses after you have acceded to your man. The commenter’s all have
    in common their first hand knowledge of the problem with too sheer fabrics,
    questioning Lu – Lulemon why only the Luon pants and crops are
    being addressed and not the entire line. They key is finding the one that will relieve your migraine.

    my web-site … sun gym victorian clothing for sale

  10. Williams Says:

    Thanks to my father who stated to me concerning this blog, this blog is really
    remarkable.

    Here is myy page; deal on long beach dinner (Williams)

 

Leave a Reply